Cast & Characters
Jaden Miller — Keeper
Taylor as Catherine Elwood
Taylor as Catherine Elwood
The Keeper: it is impossible to tell what he is making up, and what is well prepared.
Taylor as Catherine Elwood
Taylor as Catherine Elwood
Taylor as Catherine Elwood
The Flake: a student psychologist tangled in her family’s dark legacy.
Quentin as Charlie Sterns
Taylor as Catherine Elwood
Joey as Sammy “Knuck” Accardiano
The Searcher: an investigative journalist chasing forbidden truths.
Joey as Sammy “Knuck” Accardiano
Joey as Sammy “Knuck” Accardiano
Joey as Sammy “Knuck” Accardiano
The Crooked: a rum-runner trying to build an empire and protect the people he loves.
Ross as Harry Henderson
Joey as Sammy “Knuck” Accardiano
Ross as Harry Henderson
The Gumshoe: a war-weary private detective with a moral compass and a revolver.
Behind the Screen
Whispers of Old Harbor intentionally dodges the mystery-of-the-week structure, but instead layers longform arcs, family secrets, and cosmic themes. From haunted manors and unraveling time loops, every clue pushed the characters closer to an impossible truth—and a heartbreaking choice.
The story evolved organically around player choices, with recurring motifs of water, sacrifice, and memory.